Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Partly, perhaps. For me, a large part is the notation. I know conditionals, I know loops (as in for loops), I know SQL... but if you show me logic, set theory, a sigma, or, uh, what's this sigma but for multiplication, I wouldn't have known what you meant a few years ago. It's not only understanding the math, it's also the notation.

I still don't know how to read things like curly braces or matrices or a dozen other things that I don't even know the name for, and figuring it out is usually more work than it's worth. As a result, I don't understand Wikipedia articles that are supposed to be introductory and understandable to the masses, but because the article's writers are being fancy, it's only understandable for a privileged few. Often the concepts, if I do bother to understand them or look them up elsewhere, are rather simple.

It also doesn't help that people use things incorrectly or ambiguously. Sometimes a line over some math will mean the average (or "mean", to use the ambiguous lingo) and sometimes it's an infinite repetition.

Or the lingo: a friend of my girlfriend was baffled I didn't have X in school and didn't know what it was (I think it's derivations). She kind of explained it to me and I kind of understood, not recognising it. Later that evening I used it, unknowingly, in programming. When showing my girlfriend what I made she pointed it out to me.

Heck, I recently used logarithms fairly intuitively where they were never properly explained to me. I just knew the formula for entropy calculation (log(possibilities)/log(2)) by heart and managed to make something that converts a number from any base into any base (e.g. base 13 to base 19). I can do math, just nobody bothered to tell me about the fancy symbols. To me, the symbols mainly seek to obfuscate, look smart, and ensure job security.



Pretty much every math textbook I've read has defined the notational conventions early on.

(I'm not saying this is the case with every math text, just the ones I've read that are intended to teach the reader the subject.)

I see all these comments about reading papers with confusion and I get the impression that they didn't read the prerequisite information from textbooks for whom they're the right audience as that's generally how you pick up notation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: