You could say the same thing about Google and Facebook versus Twitter or Snapchat. Whatever strategies they did find and implement likely worked or were massively improved upon using the historic data the firm had on how to position quotes, what trades weren't liquidity constrained, what were the server response delays between exchanges, etc.
Think about the quality between Google Maps and Apple Maps when Apple maps was first launched. Apple even hired a bunch of ex-Google Maps employees to improve their product, so it likely was using similar algorithms, but with worse data. Apple though had the luxury of gathering every iPhone user's location data though to build up their dataset. In Rentech's case, a competing hedge fund would not only have to build out the team and infrastructure, they would only likely lose a lot of money at first to gather enough data to have a similar edge. There were a lot of HFT firms like Jump, Citadel's unit, Getco that generated very impressive risk-adjusted returns for a while, but I don't believe it was close to Rentech in terms of capital capacity and number of years.
> You could say the same thing about Google and Facebook versus Twitter or Snapchat.
You can't. Renaissance only hire ~100-150 people, their strategy is very much based on only hiring the best of the best. This is nothing like tech. Tech firms employ thousands of engineers, you have to employ average people if your demand is this high.
Jump and Citadel aren't trying to do what RenTech does either (it is very hard and very risky). They do a lot of HFT, afaik Jump is just a market maker, so they are more like tech companies in that they do not need geniuses. They just need competent bodies at scale who won't blow up the company.
Think about the quality between Google Maps and Apple Maps when Apple maps was first launched. Apple even hired a bunch of ex-Google Maps employees to improve their product, so it likely was using similar algorithms, but with worse data. Apple though had the luxury of gathering every iPhone user's location data though to build up their dataset. In Rentech's case, a competing hedge fund would not only have to build out the team and infrastructure, they would only likely lose a lot of money at first to gather enough data to have a similar edge. There were a lot of HFT firms like Jump, Citadel's unit, Getco that generated very impressive risk-adjusted returns for a while, but I don't believe it was close to Rentech in terms of capital capacity and number of years.